It ain’t bad! I’ve had a couple of meals there now, and based on my limited sampling, I like it.
Burnt ends (aka brisket trimmings; pictured): great. Not too mushy, not too chewy. Could the meat be a bit smokier? Yes, but it’s not a disaster.
French fries: very, very good. They wouldn’t be out of place on a steak frites plate.
Coleslaw: it’s a creamy, fairly classic style. Fine by me.
Collards: great texture but sadly lacking in flavor despite the chunks of pork lurking amongst the greens. Several generous squirts of the housemade hot sauce fixed them up. GREAT hot sauce, by the way.
Housemade spicy pickles: a slightly sophisticated take on the standard bread and butter chips. Sweet but not aggressively so, and an excellent foil for rich meats.
I’ve got my eye on the kielbasa for the next go-round, and the fried cherry pie…
Townline BBQ, 3593 Townline Road at Montauk Highway, Sagaponack, NY






